Market cut · United States

Leading Insurance Brands in AI Search in the United States

The Insurance index re-ranked using only prompts and answers from United States.

October 2026 edition

Across the six months through October 2026, Amica leads AI search visibility in Insurance in United States with a Goodie visibility score of 76.0, ahead of Northwestern Mutual (75.6) and Erie Insurance (59.6). The median score across the 20 ranked brands is 37.0, and a score above 37.2 reaches the top ten. The most-cited source grounding these answers is reddit.com at 5.0% of all citations, while brand-owned pages account for just 16.4%.

35k prompts · 2.6m AI answers · 11.3m citations · Goodie AI Visibility Index

Industry Benchmarks

October 2026 · Insurance · United States
What good looks like in this category. Read a brand's own score against these before looking at who is winning.
Median visibility score
37.0
Half of the 20 ranked insurance brands score below this. The midpoint, not the average, so a few dominant brands do not distort it.
Index-wide median is 73.0
Score to enter the top 10
37.2
Clearing 37.2 puts a brand in the category top ten. The bar sits 0.3 points above the midpoint, so the leaderboard is closely contested.
Brands named per answer
9.1
A typical answer names nine brands, so the consideration set is wide and a mention is comparatively easy to earn.
Index-wide average is 8.2
Citation mix
  • UGC 4%
  • Editorial 4%
  • Video 1%
  • Reference 12%
  • Other 79%
Other leads the third-party sources grounding insurance answers. Brand-owned citations sit in the next cell and are not counted here. “Other” covers domains we have not classified into a type yet.
Brand-owned citation share
16.4%
Owned content is weak here: third-party sources decide most of these answers.
Index-wide average is 26.8%
Industry sentiment
59/100
Mean tone of mentions across the ranked brands that carry a measured value. Per-brand sentiment sits on each brand profile.
Prompts sampled
35k
Real buyer phrasing, 4 models
AI answers analysed
2.6m
325k in October · ▲ 8.7% vs September
Citations parsed
11.3m
1m in October · ▼ 3.1% vs September
Brands observed
959
20 ranked here · 939 unranked

Brand Visibility Leaderboard

Brand visibility leaderboard for Insurance, ranked by six-month average AI visibility score
#BrandVisibility scoreShare of voiceModelsΔ vs last monthSentimentTop cited source
01Amica
76.0
9.9%AI ModeChatGPTCopilotPerplexity—74insurance.com
02Northwestern Mutual
75.6
9.8%AI ModeChatGPTCopilotPerplexity▼ 1.875newyorklife.com
03Erie Insurance
59.6
7.8%ChatGPTCopilotPerplexity—69insurance.com
04Islamic Arab Insurance Company
58.0
7.6%ChatGPTCopilotPerplexity▼ 0.256imarcgroup.com
05Guardian Life
57.7
7.5%AI ModeCopilotPerplexity▼ 0.865newyorklife.com
06MassMutual
57.1
7.4%ChatGPTCopilotPerplexity—66newyorklife.com
07Kaiser Permanente
57.1
7.4%AI ModeChatGPTCopilot▲ 0.278forbes.com
08USAA
39.9
5.2%AI ModePerplexity▲ 0.263insurance.com
09GEICO
38.0
4.9%AI ModeChatGPT—64insurance.com
10Qatar Islamic Insurance Company
37.2
4.8%ChatGPTCopilot▲ 0.751imarcgroup.com
20 ranked · visibility is a six-month averageTop source = most frequent source in answers mentioning the brand · Δ compares Oct with Sep

Most-Cited Domains

The answer supply chain
Most-cited domains in AI answers for Insurance
#DomainCitation shareΔ vs last month
01reddit.com
5.0%
—
02jdpower.com
4.4%
▼ 0.7
03ethos.com
4.1%
—
04youtube.com
3.7%
—
05wikipedia.org
3.7%
—
06policybazaar.com
3.6%
—
07takaful-malaysia.com.my
3.6%
—
08insurance.com
2.8%
▲ 0.4
09ambest.com
2.8%
▼ 1.7
10cnbc.com
2.7%
—
Top 10 of 1k domains observedΔ compares Oct with Sep, in percentage points

Prompts, Topics & Movers

What's driving this month's answers

Sampled prompts

Prompts sampled for Insurance, with distinct brands named and sources cited
#PromptBrandsSources
01Life insurance providers with strong financial ratings74177
02Takaful insurance providers popular in the region134152
03Auto insurance companies trusted by drivers46149
04Health insurance providers with smooth claims experience57146
05Which insurance companies settle claims fastest?5993
5 of 35k sampledDistinct brands named & sources cited

Biggest movers

Oct vs Sep
Rising
Alrajhi Takafulscore 20.1
▲ 2.7
Tawuniyascore 20.0
▲ 1.2
State Farmscore 17.9
▲ 0.9
Falling
▼ 1.8
Guardian Lifescore 57.7
▼ 0.8
New York Lifescore 20.3
▼ 0.5
13 ranked brands scored in both Sep and OctIndustry avg ±0.9/mo

Global Search Demand

Where this industry's questions originate
5,279,035 searches sampled
Tracked markets for Insurance, by sampled search volume
#CountrySearch volume
01United States3.1M
02United Kingdom940K
03Japan337K
04Canada245K
05Australia225K
06Germany141K
07Saudi Arabia99K
08France43K
09United Arab Emirates43K
10Italy41K
11Egypt41K
12Singapore28K
12 tracked markets
This edition

What Changed This Month

Amica leads Insurance this edition with a visibility score of 76.0, ahead of Northwestern Mutual at 75.6.

reddit.com is the most-cited source grounding insurance answers, at roughly 5.0% of citations. Brand-owned pages account for 16.4% — the rest of the answer supply chain runs through third-party sources.

The median visibility score across ranked insurance brands is 37.0, and a score above 37.2 reaches the industry top ten.

Free brand check · no signup

Where Does Your Brand Stand in AI Search?

Enter a domain to see its visibility score, strongest industry, model gaps, competitors ahead, and the sources grounding its answers.

31 industries4 models355m+ citation observationsFree unlimited checks
What you get
  • Visibility score
  • Industry rank
  • Brands ahead of you
  • Model and source gaps
Our Methodology

Our Approach to Gathering AI Visibility Data

We process millions of real prompts across AI Mode, ChatGPT, Copilot and Perplexity, then track which brands, products, and domains show up in the answers. That's the raw data behind every score in the Index.

Real Intent Capture

This data results from processing millions of real user prompts. We use advanced semantic and agentic processing to categorize them and define intent, filtering out noise to focus on high-value queries.

Global Model Interrogation

We run these prompts across the tracked models and across every market we cover, so each market is scored on its own answers rather than on a global average applied everywhere.

Attribution Mapping

We analyze the generated answers to capture the "Kingmaker" domains: the specific sources models cite most often in the answers that name a brand, so you can see which sources the models lean on where you appear and where you do not.

Three-dimensional logo of Goodie, an end-to-end AI search visibility platform.
FAQ · Insurance

Questions?
We Have
the Answers.

Amica currently leads AI search visibility in insurance with a Goodie visibility score of 76.0, measured across the tracked AI models.

reddit.com is the most-cited source in insurance AI answers, grounding roughly 5.0% of citations in this industry.

The median score among ranked insurance brands is 37.0. A score above 37.2 places a brand in the industry top ten.

Each edition samples the same tracked prompt set across the models Goodie follows, then ranks brands by how often they are named in those answers.

Monthly. Each edition re-samples the tracked prompt set so month-over-month figures are directly comparable.